The internets are abuzz with news from The Smoking Gun that James Frey's memoir A MILLION LITTLE PIECES may be greatly fabricated. The NY Times is writing about it. And there are no comments from everyone...James isn't answering his phone, Random House is silent, Oprah is silent and the internets...full o' anger and comments.
I have a signed first edition of A MILLION LITTLE PIECES. I was one of the first people to read it when the galleys came out. I snagged it pretty fast and loved it. I devoured it and I never really wondered or needed it to be absolutely factual. I could have cared less frankly.
I met James at a bookseller's luncheon and he seems to be a pretty sincere guy. Someone who wanted to write a book...not a book on it's way to be a screenplay. Which...I hear he has sold the screenplay and a movie is in the works.
I don't know what to say or think. I believe everyone is truthful for the most part. Maybe it's cynical...but I'm the type of person who just trusts people. And I lived in NYC for 5 years. And my apartment was broken in to. And still...I'll leave money on the door for the pizza guy and expect him to leave the pizza. (Which by the way...he did leave...just he put it on the back porch so for awhile I didn't feel so good about my general belief in people. Then I just wished I had looked on the back porch instead of calling hours later and asking about it.)
I noticed in the last few weeks that people searching for the phrase "james frey is a liar" got directed to my blog, mostly due to my typelist of books I've read. I thought to myself...why do people spend time doing this?
I feel bad for James. If the memoir is composed of lies...many people are rolled up into all this. Including his parents...who appeared on the Oprah Show. And Oprah's fact checkers, who did some research on all of this.
A lot of people are comparing this case to the J.T. LeRoy saga...which I somewhat disagree with. But maybe both J.T. LeRoy and James Frey "invented" themselves from the best and worst parts of themselves. Maybe we believe them because it helps us feel like better people to do so. I'm not sure. All I'm sure of is...this will be a huge thing for a good amount of time and then...as all things do...it will pass and we will be obsessed with something else.
Like Chad Lowe and Hilary Swank.
UPDATE: James will be appearing on LARRY KING LIVE tonight to talk about these allegations. He won't be there for the full hour according to the LKL publicist. We'll see what happens after this train wreck. Hopefully, I'll be able to have a friend TIVO or DVR it for me as I am cableless.
Recent Comments